A smile meets the noise of a building site: How places shape our empathy
HU study examines the influence of the environment on emotional reactions to other people
Two people bump into each other by chance in the street. A first glance, a smile – perhaps the start of a connection? When we first meet someone, we usually know nothing about them. But it is not just their face, their clothes or our assumptions about them that matter: the setting can also influence how open we are towards others. Researchers at the Department of Psychology at Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin (HU), working under the supervision of Dr Till Kastendieck in Prof. Dr Ursula Hess’s Social and Organisational Psychology group, were able to demonstrate this in a study. The study, funded by the German Research Foundation (DFG), was recently published in “Scientific Reports”, the largest open-access journal published as part of the Nature Portfolio.
The study focused on what is known in technical terms as ‘emotional mimicry’: people often unconsciously imitate at least some aspects of other people’s emotional expressions. Emotional mimicry is regarded as an indicator of affective empathy – emotional resonance – and is linked to the need to establish closeness and connection with other people. It was already known that social factors such as familiarity influence this mimicry. The effect of the spatial atmosphere, on the other hand, has hardly been researched to date.
A virtual park, two spatial atmospheres
In the social psychophysiological laboratory at HU, 75 participants used VR headsets to explore two areas of a 3D park landscape, which had been specially designed using the ‘Unreal Engine’ development tool – a tool otherwise used primarily for other applications: a peaceful, leafy area with birdsong, blooming cherry trees and a picturesque pond; and a second area characterised by construction vehicles and machinery, along with loud, rumbling construction noise.
There, the participants encountered unfamiliar virtual characters – avatars – whose individual characteristics were randomly generated. These avatars initially displayed neutral facial expressions, followed by happy, sad, angry or disgusted ones. The participants were asked to imagine that these characters might speak to them at any moment. However, the study focused exclusively on non-verbal communication during the first few seconds of the encounter – that brief, unique moment that can never be repeated in exactly the same way between two people and whose significance is probably often underestimated due to its fleeting nature.
“Our findings show that the valence of the environment – that is, whether it is perceived as pleasant or unpleasant – influences the reaction to unfamiliar faces,” says Dr Kastendieck. A smile from the avatar elicited a stronger facial response in the quiet area of the park, whilst negative facial expressions elicited a stronger response in the noisy construction site area. There, negative facial reactions were sometimes observed even in response to a neutral facial expression. In the pleasant area, participants also felt somewhat closer socially to smiling avatars. Furthermore, joy and sadness were recognised somewhat more distinctly there. This suggests a small effect on cognitive empathy – that is, the ability to recognise others’ emotional expressions.
What made this experiment unique was that sensors were integrated into the VR headsets, which recorded even the slightest electrical activity in the facial muscles around the eyes, cheeks and forehead. Normally, VR headsets cover precisely these areas. The combination of immersive virtual reality and facial electromyography (EMG) made it possible to specifically alter the environment whilst simultaneously measuring barely visible facial reactions. “A major advantage of this method is, of course, that experiments can be designed to be relatively lifelike, whilst certain experimental factors can still be specifically controlled,” explains Dr Kastendieck.
Implications for everyday life
Designed as a contribution to basic research, the study investigates ‘embedded social cognition’: in other words, the question of how the processing of social information is embedded in contexts. However, it also raises practical questions: could noise and other disruptive stimuli make a positive encounter more difficult – for example, in waiting areas or at workstations? Such everyday effects have not yet been proven. After all, the study analysed encounters with avatars rather than real-life encounters. Furthermore, spatial and social characteristics can never be completely separated. The study does, however, point out that a location is not merely the backdrop to an encounter, but can either foster or disrupt our empathetic response to other people, which is deeply rooted in human biology.
Publication:
Environmental context effects on affective and cognitive empathy in virtual reality
Kastendieck, T., Huppertz, D., Mauersberger, H. & Hess, U.
Scientific Reports, 16, 25476 (2026). www.nature.com/articles/s41598-026-66551-9
Contact:
Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin
Department of Psychology
www.psychologie.hu-berlin.de
Dr. Till Kastendieck
till.kastendieck(at)hu-berlin.de
Prof. Dr. Ursula Hess
+49 30 2093-98702
ursula.hess(at)hu-berlin.de
HU press release, 18 November 2026
